David Mitchell
Monica,
Interesting comments about Catholic priest celibacy. A very touchy subject which could get us into some trouble here on this forum - but I agree that is not only ironic, but sad. I believe at some time in the recent past, there were at least three American Roman Catholic bishops who were either former Lutheran or Episcopalian- and they were married with children. I went though life believing the "Church's" reason for this - "to be more like Christ and the apostles". Uhh, excuse me, several of the apostles were married men.
When I later read the history of the real reason (not till my fifties) did I wonder why we can't simply go back to that again (and why they never taught us this in the first place). Priests were often married unitl about the year 1,000 or maybe 1,200. What finally forced the Church to insist on Celibacy on a permanent basis was the problem of nepostism. If I am not mistaken here, priests owned the church properties and passed them on to their sons. Gradually, they acquired more and more property and became powerful landlords and eventually "rulers". We can read of many instances where the medieval Bishops were also powerful temporal Princes, with vast land holdings and military armies (and nasty wars).
I often wonder why we simply cannot own up to this kind of stuff and move on? But then I recall it only took the Church 350 years to "pardon" Galileo.
My father, a life-long ultra-conservative Catholic, used to refer to this problem as the "Vatican Control Syndrome". He used to accuse them of spending all their time writing rules, and then more rules, and then rules about the rules - instead of teaching us about the many wonderful "promises" Christ made to us. He even went so far as to say that the only function he could see in the Curia was to "suck the spiritual life out of the Church". Dad was actually the first Catholic layman to be allowed to give the homily at a Catholic Mass in the Diocese of Columbus (at OLP). That priveledge has long since been revoked (newer rules). I have always believed that Dad (as well as my Father in law, Dr. Tom Hughes - and several other dads I knew) would have made terrific priests. They were true "servant leaders".
I wonder what it will take.
|