David Mitchell
The discussion this week between some of us has reached an interesting point. Another article, wrtitten in a very cogent and logical manner (this time) is put forth about two comparative evils in our lives. Well reasoned and very thought provoking.
How evil was this, and which is a greater evil - a "bump stock" in the hands of a mad man, or the razor sharp "currette" and suction device in the hands of some "doctors"?
One helps bullets puncture and rip through the human body, the other slices it to pieces before extraction.
I imagine you could all guess, that I am appalled by, and opposed to both. So I am therefore in total agreement with multiple points of view. But I tend to cringe at the use of that argument to fan the flames of the other. I wish that we could keep the two arguments separate - conceeding that will be (emotionally) difficult. Or at least let a cooling off period of time before bringing those two up in the same breath.
But I also agree with one very important point of view in the other classmate's reply. It saddens me that so much of our upbringing in our "Faith" is based on almost two millenia of a Church that long ago drifted from it's origin based on the many "promises" of Christ, to the need for worldly authority and control at all costs. Reading the Church's own history, one is shocked by the powerful manipulation, fear tactics, and outright crimes employed by Rome throught the ages. The Crusades, the Spanish Inquisistion, and the "selling" of indulgeneces by Tetzel in the 1500's, are some of the most noteworthy. I myself am quite fascinated by a few of the late 19th century's Pope's attempts to hold onto the Papal States (mostly for tax revenues) with iron fisted controls - through the use of moslty brutal French and Austian troops. They actully forbade Catholics to join unions, to vote, to hold office, or run for office - or to own or read a Bible!
The penalty was death. And that's in the late 1800's folks!
But more to the point - in our own lives, I recall some of the manipulation we experienced. One such thing was the Friday "examination of conscience". It was hard to imagine how a boy like me - going through puberty with a class full of cute "babes" - could avoid hell - week after week, after week. And it did leave some scars.
The overall lesson of life we got from the good Sisters was "You'd better be good, or God will not love you." I have long since come to beleive that it should have been - "You already are good, because God loves you so much that He wants you to be with Him forever."
Before we ever had organized religion, there was one itinerant, homelsss, young troublemaker from a small backwater town in Galilee, who I beleive came to free us from "religion". He is quoted as saying;
"For even the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.” (And he did exactly that !)
*I really believe in the end, His "argument" will beat all of ours. And I'm betting all I have on it!
Have a fantastic day tomorrow - I need to go check out Mitch Trubisky)
|