John Jackson
I’ll try a different tack by encouraging MM to turn down the histrionics and look at the facts. Below are U.S. Customs and Border Patrol statistics on border crossings from 2018 through roughly the first half of 2021 (CBP keeps statistics on a U.S. fiscal year basis which runs from Oct. 1 through Sept. 30).
In the top figure the blue curve is 2021 (still incomplete) and the orange curve is 2018 showing total “encounters” at the southern border. This data shows the ebbs and flows of migration that are affected not only by U.S. policy but also by the seasons and conditions (gang violence, drug dealing, government repression of minorities and corruption) in Central America. Let’s remember that 2018 was two years into Trump’s attempt to brutalize immigrants/asylum seekers at the southern border by taking their kids away and using other tactics I doubt the Church’s teaching on social justice would countenance. To be sure, the curve for 2021 is a bit higher than the orange curve but it’s not the total meltdown you describe in your post (another example of the baseless hyperbole that right wing media persist in feeding to their followers).
And in the bar charts at the bottom, you’ll see that the number of unaccompanied children (UAC) is still a tiny fraction of this year’s encounters. And if you double the tiny blue bar for 2021 (which shows only half the year) it looks to me that it will very close to the height of the orange bar that shows full numbers for 2018.
The main change Biden has made is that we’re no longer sending unaccompanied minors from Central America back to Mexico (not their native country). For other much larger categories (single adults and families) the granting of asylum or immigrant status has changed very little, although I’m guessing those who are turned back or held for immigration hearings are at least treated with respect.
I’m not suggesting that the more humane policies of the Biden administration have had no effect in encouraging more people to try to cross the border but it appears that the total numbers aren’t much higher than the bad old days of 2018. And if a modest increase is the price we pay for treating these desperate people with compassion and respect, I’m OK with it.
|